AI Is Actually Making Workers Less Productive
Generative AI tools promised increased productivity but have instead increased workloads and contributed to burnout, a survey from Upwork shows. Companies need to reassess their expectations and better support employees to effectively integrate AI as a technology.
Generative AI tools, meant to eliminate time-consuming tasks and boost productivity in the workplace, haven't yet delivered on that promise. In fact, right now they're doing the opposite - giving employees more work and contributing to burnout.
Increased Workload With AI
A survey by Upwork of over 2,500 full-time employees, freelancers, and managers found that nearly 80% of those using generative AI at work feel it has increased their workload and reduced their productivity. Workers are spending more time reviewing or moderating AI-generated content and more time learning to use the tools, which differs greatly from employers' expectations. About 96% of managers expect AI to increase productivity, while about 40% of employees don't know how that will ever happen.
The Need for Realistic Expectations
Emily Rose McRae, senior director analyst at Gartner, says the current hype around AI is disproportionate to the actual impact the technology can have right now, especially given how it's being implemented. Many companies have unrealistic expectations about AI's ability to reduce staffing needs, which rarely matches reality.
Imperfect Tools
Generative AI tools are still prone to hallucinating or fabricating answers that sound plausible, which means human involvement is needed to double-check the material. This can be time-consuming and increases the risk of errors. In some cases, AI tools can save time, such as in law, where AI can help lawyers research and analyze large amounts of information. But even here, human review is needed to ensure accuracy.
The Importance of Human Oversight
Kelly Monahan, managing director and head of the Upwork Research Institute, emphasizes that large language models work best when a human is involved and overseeing the process. To truly capture the productivity gains from AI, companies must reassess their work methods and how AI can help solve business problems.
Supporting Employees
Many employees feel their company is asking too much of them when it comes to AI, and they're investing a lot of time in learning to use the tools themselves. Employers can better support their employees by holding focus groups to identify obstacles and offering targeted training. It's also important to be open to feedback that AI tools don't always meet needs.
Future Training
In the future, employers may begin training staff to spot AI hallucinations, similar to phishing training. Employees will learn to be skeptical of AI-generated content and report questionable cases to help improve the language models.