AI in Marketing Does More Harm Than Good

A study shows that mentioning AI in marketing can reduce consumer trust and willingness to buy, especially for high-risk products. So what can you do if you want to use AI in your marketing while still keeping consumer trust?

Share
AI in Marketing Does More Harm Than Good

A study led by Washington State University (WSU) and published in the Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management shows that explicit mentions of AI in product descriptions can deter potential buyers, despite AI's growing presence in consumer goods.

Trust Declines When Content Is Labeled AI

The study, which surveyed over 1,000 American adults, found that products labeled with AI consistently performed worse.

Mesut Cicek, lead author from WSU, noted: "AI mentions reduce emotional trust, which hurts willingness to buy."

Tests were conducted across different categories - smart TVs, high-tech electronics, medical devices, and financial services. Participants received identical product descriptions that differed only in the presence or absence of the term "artificial intelligence."

Impact on High-Risk Products

Resistance to AI was strongest for "high-risk" products, meaning products that could cause major financial or safety problems if something goes wrong. These products create more worry and uncertainty among consumers.

Cicek said:

"We tested the effect across eight different product and service categories, and the results were the same: it's a disadvantage to use such terms in product descriptions."

Implications for Marketers

The most important takeaway for marketers is to reevaluate their AI messaging. Cicek recommends carefully weighing mentions of AI or developing strategies to strengthen emotional trust.

Focus on the product's features and benefits, not the AI technology. "Avoid AI buzzwords," Cicek warns, especially for high-risk products.

The research emphasizes that emotional trust is a key factor in how AI products are perceived.

Looking Ahead

AI's growing presence in everyday life highlights the need for careful communication about its capabilities in consumer-facing content.

Marketers and product teams should reevaluate how they present AI labeling, balancing transparency and consumer confidence.

The study, co-authored by WSU professor Dogan Gursoy and Temple University associate professor Lu Lu, lays the groundwork for further research into consumer perceptions of AI in different contexts.

As AI continues to evolve, companies must keep pace with changing consumer attitudes and adjust their marketing accordingly.