AI Gets Fired From Its Job - Literally

Can AI really replace human news anchors? After two months of robotic performances and negative reviews, The Garden Island has scrapped its experiment. Is this the end for AI journalists?

Share
AI Gets Fired From Its Job - Literally

James and Rose, two AI news anchors introduced by the local newspaper The Garden Island in Hawaii, have been fired after just two months. Their performance as virtual hosts in the US's first AI-powered news program was met with sharp criticism and negative reactions from both the public and media colleagues.

An Ambitious Project, Negative Reactions

The AI anchors, developed by the Israeli company Caledo, were part of a pilot project to turn articles into videos where AI hosts discuss the news. The program aired on YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram and was meant to expand to hundreds of local newspapers in the US. Although Caledo describes the trial as a success, the broad negative response appears to have put an end to the project.

James, designed as a middle-aged Asian man, and Rose, a younger red-haired woman, failed to create an engaging, human-feeling news broadcast. Their robotic performances and struggles with both pronunciation and context often made the program feel "dystopian."

Harsh Criticism From Viewers: "Terrifying"

Comments on social media were overwhelmingly negative. One viewer called the program "terrifying," while a local media organization held up the AI anchors as an example of the threat to traditional journalism. "You no longer have to imagine a world where local journalism is created by algorithms. That dystopia is here, and it's frightening," wrote Ben Nishimoto of Honolulu Civil Beat.

Underperforming Technology and Ad Revenue

The technology behind James and Rose improved somewhat over the course of the project. For example, James went from being unable to blink and having shaky hands to blinking regularly and making the occasional gesture. But these small improvements weren't enough to save the experiment.

The program also failed to generate any income through ads, even though Caledo claimed advertising would cover the costs. The main sponsor, Longs Drugs, also turned out not to have even been informed that its logo was being used in the broadcasts.

Wasted Resources in an Already Strained Industry

Many critics pointed out that the resources going into the AI program could have been used to strengthen traditional journalism. The Garden Island is already underfunded, with only two reporters to cover the news on an island of 73,000 residents.

James and Rose may have been an ambitious attempt to automate local news, but they couldn't compete with human journalism when it comes to delivering credible, engaging reporting.