Adobe's AI Model Firefly Under Ethical Scrutiny

Adobe Firefly faces ethical scrutiny after reports that the AI model used unlicensed images from competitor Midjourney. Despite this, Adobe assures that its AI image generator remains safe from copyright claims.

Share
Adobe's AI Model Firefly Under Ethical Scrutiny

Adobe has marketed its AI image generator Firefly as an ethical AI solution, trained on millions of licensed images from Adobe's own library. But according to a new report from Bloomberg, this image might not be as spotless as Adobe would like. The model, described as "commercially safe," may have used images from competitor Midjourney, a startup suspected of scraping images from the internet without a license.

Adobe states that only about 5% of the millions of images used to train Firefly came from this source, and that all of these images were part of the Adobe Stock library, meaning they went through a "rigorous moderation process."

Firefly's Safety Commitments and Artists' Hesitancy

When Adobe launched Firefly, it offered indemnification against copyright infringement claims for its enterprise customers, as a way to reassure them of its safety. Adobe has also marketed Firefly as a safe alternative to competitors Midjourney and DALL-E, since all data was licensed and approved for use in model training. Despite this, not all artists were convinced at the time and felt pressured into letting their work be used by the tech giant.

Despite revelations that some images came from potentially less reliable sources, Adobe assures that all non-human images remain safe. An Adobe spokesperson told Bloomberg that "every image submitted to Adobe Stock, including a very small portion of AI-generated images, undergoes a rigorous moderation process to ensure it doesn't include intellectual property, trademarks, recognizable characters or logos, or references to artists' names."

The company appears to be taking further steps in its plans to build an AI video generator. Rumors suggest they're paying artists per minute for video clips.